Update: High Court to rule Friday on State bid to strike out video of raid on Makebi Zulu's home as Mundubile bail fight continues

JUSTICE

By ZPP Newsroom

Source: Zambia Monitor

Update: High Court to rule Friday on State bid to strike out video of raid on Makebi Zulu's home as Mundubile bail fight continues
The State has set out its case for striking out the video evidence, the defence has replied, and the High Court has fixed 11:00 on Friday 13 November to rule. The State wants the Lusaka High Court to remove five paragraphs of an Affidavit in Reply, and a flash disk holding a video, from the record in the constitutional bail application of opposition leader Brian Mundubile, Makebi Zulu and 16 others. The court has set 11:00 on Friday 13 November to rule on the objection and to hear the bail application itself. The Director of Public Prosecutions and his team told the three-judge panel of Justices Derrick Mulenga, Davies Chibwili and Ireen Wishimanga that the material brings in new matters beyond the scope of a reply and leaves the State no chance to answer. The State also questioned the video's authenticity, origin and integrity. It relied on Section 9 of the Electronic Communications and Transactions Act and on the case of OTK Limited v Amanita Zambia Limited and Others, and argued that electronic evidence must be authenticated before a court admits it. Counsel for the applicants opposed the application. They said the disputed paragraphs answer the State's claim that Mr Mundubile and Mr Zulu are flight risks, and that doubts about the video go to how much weight the court gives it and not to whether it can be admitted. Mr Zulu, who argues his own case as the second applicant, said the affidavit was properly sworn before a Commissioner for Oaths and filed, that the State's demands apply to oral testimony at trial and not to affidavit proceedings, and that a flash disk is a document under the Evidence Act. The court noted that the matter is constitutional but has criminal implications. Defence lawyer Sakwiba Sikota has said the video shows what happened when security officers raided Mr Zulu's home, and that the State appeared uncomfortable with it. ### Background The 18 applicants have been held on treason charges since August at Mukobeko Maximum Correctional Fa